Why I’ve Grown to Hate Most Employee Feedback Systems

360degreeIn the past 22 years, I have noticed that most corporations solicit feedback from all levels of a team, but when using them to *help* an employee improve, the feedback is used in a way that leaves out specifics, so that the help is not really actionable. Is anonymous, context-free feedback the best we can do?

Rather than rant and rave on this, here is a lovely article by Liz Ryan of the Human Workplace that addresses many of the current feedback systems shortcomings.

I was a fan of 360-degree feedback for a year or two when the idea first hit the HR world around 1990. I’m not going to say that I regret my enthusiasm back then, because life is all learning, but I certainly don’t feel the same way today.

I hate 360-degree feedback systems as much as I hate Forced Ranking programs. They’re both vile. It’s just that 360-degree feedback comes wrapped in Employee Development wrapping, whereas Forced Ranking has always looked exactly like what it is: a crude and cynical way to scare people and keep them rattled, and a way to justify chopping heads.

We’ve always known that stacking people up one against the other is the world’s worst way to lead. Our clients have been quietly shedding their Forced Ranking systems for a decade now. These organizations have evolved past the need to pit teammates against one another in a real-life version of Survivor: Battle for the Last Cubicle.

Read more …

About Gandalfe

Just an itinerant saxophonist trying to find life between the changes. I have retired from the Corps of Engineers and Microsoft. I am an admin on the Woodwind Forum, run the Seattle Solid GOLD Big Band (formerly the Microsoft Jumpin' Jive Orchestra) a GOLD sax quartet, and enjoy time with family and friends.
This entry was posted in Education, Employment, FAQ, Guides and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Why I’ve Grown to Hate Most Employee Feedback Systems

  1. juliovaz says:

    I tend to agree with these thoughts. The question becomes on of how to effectively lead folks to improve when most managers wind up spending time on minutiae that takes time away from interacting with their team. When teams were smaller and local it was easier to lead than with global-spanning teams.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s